
Episode 112 · September 19, 2023
Nancy Bolzle: Founder of The Pencil Box, Providing free school supplies to teachers of disadvantaged students
with Nancy Bolzle, Founder of The Pencil Box
27 min
Nancy Bolzle: Founder of The Pencil Box, Providing free school supplies to teachers of disadvantaged students
Never miss an episode
In this episode
In this episode I sit down with my friend and sorority sister Nancy Bolzle, the founder of The Pencil Box — a Tulsa nonprofit that operates like a free store where teachers can "shop" for the school supplies their students need. Nancy shares her path from at-home mom and volunteer to contract lobbyist at the Oklahoma State Capitol, and how that work advocating for children, family, and education planted the seed for what she'd build in retirement.
I love that Nancy leads with a simple conviction: every child deserves a quality education regardless of their ZIP code. She walks us through the sobering numbers — Oklahoma consistently ranks near the bottom for education — and how something as small as a pencil can shape a child's grades, creativity, confidence, and belief in their own possibilities. Since the first distribution in 2015, The Pencil Box has given away $6 million worth of supplies and impacted more than 200,000 students and 1,700 teachers.
We also get honest about what it really takes to start and grow a nonprofit — the years of legwork before the doors ever open, the challenge of funding an organization that gives away tangible product, and how the team pivoted during the pandemic by delivering supplies straight to schools. If you've ever dreamed of turning your passion and purpose into something that serves your community, this conversation is full of encouragement and practical wisdom. Keep going.
Key takeaways
- School supplies are more than tools — studies show that having their own supplies improves children's grades, creativity, behavior, self-image, and belief in their own possibilities.
- The Pencil Box operates like a retail free store, letting teachers from qualifying schools select exactly what their students and classrooms need throughout the year — not just at back-to-school.
- The need is real: at the schools served, 82% of students arrive on the first day without supplies, 79% have nothing at home for homework, and teachers spend an average of $500 out of pocket to fill the gap.
- Before you start a nonprofit, check whether a program already exists doing what you want to do — and understand it takes hard work, strong fortitude, and years of planning (The Pencil Box's first board meeting was 2012; first distribution was 2015).
- Surround yourself with people who have the talent, expertise, and conviction to build the program, and honestly assess your ability to connect with key people and businesses in your community.
- Your dollar goes further given directly: The Pencil Box's buying power stretches one retail box of crayons into four, so cash donations and donated supplies reach students more equitably than personal drives alone.
- Being part of a village matters — The Pencil Box belongs to a national network of 40 similar programs that mentor one another, and Tulsa's culture of philanthropy has been a foundation for its growth.
“All children deserve a quality education regardless of their ZIP code.”
“Education is powerful to break the cycle of poverty. It's the first step to overcoming poverty.”
“School supplies are not going to fix the whole problem, but they're definitely a critical part of the solution.”
“The Pencil Box started around my dining room table with friends who had the talent, the expertise, and the conviction to make it happen.”
Resources mentioned
About Nancy
Founder of The Pencil Box
Nancy Bolzle is the founder of The Pencil Box, a Tulsa nonprofit that provides free school supplies to teachers of underserved students across Tulsa County. A former first-grade teacher and at-home mom, she became an advocate for children, family, and education at the Oklahoma State Capitol in 1989 and went on to work as a contract lobbyist. She retired in 2015 as The Pencil Box held its first distribution of supplies.
Prefer another app? Open this episode on Spotify.
Free community
Connect, learn, and grow — together.
Listening is where it starts. The free community is where it sticks — Nancy, the conversations, and a circle of women cheering each other on. It's free to join, and there's a seat for you.
Join the free community →Keep listening
Episode 113 · Sep 26, 2023
Show notesKelly Gibson loves a good story
Kelly Gibson owns Tours of Tulsa and has a deep love of storytelling. In this episode you'll learn more about Kelly's background and how she grew-up living at a summer camp year-round, and later on how she negotiated with her full-time…
Episode 111 · Sep 12, 2023
Show notesKristy Eller DeBoer: Shining from the Inside Out
Kristy Eller DeBoer is the founder of KED Styled. Kristy's career prior to this was behind the camera, but she has rewritten that script and now it's her time to shine in front of the camera - and she does!
Episode 114 · Oct 3, 2023
Show notesChristi Newendorp: Autism Advocate
Christi Newendorp is dedicated to improving the lives of children with special needs. As a special education teacher, Christi works with students who have a variety of needs and understands the importance of providing outstanding care and…
