All episodes
Cover art for Live at Pinspiration: Creativity Is a Muscle | Episode 258: Michelle Bruns and Susan McMurray

November 17, 2026

Live at Pinspiration: Creativity Is a Muscle | Episode 258: Michelle Bruns and Susan McMurray

38 min

Live at Pinspiration: Creativity Is a Muscle | Episode 258: Michelle Bruns and Susan McMurray

0:00–:–

In this episode

In this episode I did something a little different. We recorded live at Pinspiration Tulsa for an evening we called Cultivating Creativity, and I had the joy of sitting down with two women I admire, Michelle Bruns and Susan McMurray. If you have ever caught yourself saying "I'm just not that creative," this one is for you.

Michelle went from a graphic design degree to fifteen years running her own handmade gift line, Bright Star Designs, then bought the Pinspiration franchise right before the pandemic and opened her Tulsa studio in 2022. Susan has taught at ORU for thirty years and built the very first issue of Kindred and Bloom, a devotional in magazine form, on her couch over one summer. Two very different paths, one shared truth. You do not have to be an artist to be creative. Creativity is a muscle, and the more you use it, the stronger it gets.

We talk about letting an idea evolve instead of waiting for the full vision, why perfectionism is an enemy of creativity, and the hardest part of running a business for both of them, promotion. The women in the room brought their own questions too, and the advice that rose to the top was simple and doable. Try it on as a side hustle, take baby steps, do your homework and go for it. I love that. Keep going.

Key takeaways

  • You do not have to be an artist to be creative. Creativity shows up in writing, baking, hospitality, setting a beautiful table or making your home peaceful, not just a paintbrush and canvas.
  • Creativity is a muscle. The more you use it, the stronger it gets, so the same old born-with-it-or-not myth we outgrew about leadership applies here too.
  • You do not need the full vision before you start. Michelle designs by starting with a few ideas and letting the piece evolve, and Susan admits her first magazine spreads were terrible before she found her way.
  • Perfectionism is an enemy of creativity. Giving yourself permission to make something imperfect is often what finally gets you started.
  • Treat a new venture like a bridge year. Try it on as a side hustle, take baby steps and see if it fits before you ever walk away from a steady job.
  • Do your homework before a big leap. Michelle loves her franchise but cautions against running out to buy one without real due diligence, and points to lower-cost side hustles like a Cricut or embroidery machine.
  • Promotion and social media are the hardest part for both of them. Getting help from a dedicated social media person or an influencer connection can be a genuine game changer.
  • Free and low-cost tools lower the barrier. Canva and YouTube tutorials, royalty-free photos from Unsplash, AI for proofreading and specs, and the library's free maker space all make starting more doable than ever.

Chapters

  • 0:00Coming up
  • 0:54Live at Pinspiration: Cultivating Creativity
  • 7:26Born creative or not? Creativity is a muscle
  • 11:47Perfectionism is an enemy of creativity
  • 18:14A word from our sponsor
  • 22:37Advice for the woman who wants to start something creative
  • 37:49Sharing Passion and Purpose outro
“I think sometimes as women we think we have to be artists to be creative, and I don't think that's the case at all. It's something you develop, it's like a muscle.”
“I would say just don't put pressure on yourself to think that you have to have the vision. Just let it sort of evolve.”
“You guys should have seen some of the first spreads of the magazine. They were awful. But I learned.”
“I always tell people you don't know how it's going to turn out, but it's going to be beautiful.”

Resources mentioned

Prefer another app? Open this episode on Spotify.

Free community

Connect, learn, and grow — together.

Listening is where it starts. The free community is where it sticks — Nancy, the conversations, and a circle of women cheering each other on. It's free to join, and there's a seat for you.

Join the free community →